Cookout Secret Menu: Hidden Items & How to Order
Cook Out has no official secret menu. The cookout secret menu is a collection of fan-created custom orders: burgers, sides, shakes, and drinks assembled from regular menu ingredients that the kitchen will build if you describe exactly what you want.
That distinction matters. None of these items appear on the menu board. They have no official names, no set prices, and no guarantee that the crew on shift will recognize the nicknames fans use online. What makes them possible is simple: every item below is built from ingredients Cook Out already stocks.
Table of Contents
Why These Secret Orders Work at Cook Out
Secret menus only work at restaurants with flexible kitchens, and Cook Out qualifies. The menu is built from a small set of core ingredients that repeat across categories: beef patties, chicken, buns, tortillas, cheese, bacon, chili, fries, ice cream, and fountain drinks. Because the same ingredients appear in burgers, quesadillas, sides, and shakes, the crew can rearrange them into combinations that never made the menu board.
Secret Menu Burgers and Mains
These are the most talked-about secret orders at Cook Out. Use the exact ordering phrase in the right column, since nicknames vary by fan and by store. For the standard lineup, see our Cookout burgers guide; several builds below also start with Cookout hot dogs.
| Secret Item | What It Is | How to Order It |
|---|---|---|
| Everything Burger | A burger loaded with all available toppings and sauces | “A burger with everything on it” |
| Peanut Butter Burger | A beef patty topped with a scoop of peanut butter | “A burger with peanut butter on the patty” |
| Peanut Butter Bacon Burger | Peanut butter plus crispy bacon on a burger | “A burger with peanut butter and bacon” |
| Quesadilla Burger | A burger patty folded inside a grilled quesadilla | “A quesadilla with a burger patty inside” |
| Double Decker Burger | A double-stacked burger with two patties | “A double burger” or “two patties on one burger” |
| Chili Cheese Hot Dog | A hot dog topped with homemade chili and melted cheese | “A hot dog with chili and cheese” |
| Mexi Hot Dog | A hot dog with chili, cheese, and jalapeños | “A hot dog with chili, cheese, and jalapeños” |
| Bacon Cheddar Hot Dog | A hot dog topped with bacon and cheddar cheese | “A hot dog with bacon and cheddar” |
| BBQ Sandwich with Slaw | Chopped barbecue sandwich topped with slaw, Carolina style | “A barbecue sandwich with slaw on it” |
| Spicy Chicken Quesadilla | A quesadilla filled with spicy chicken | “A quesadilla with spicy chicken” |
Secret Menu Sides and Extras
| Secret Item | What It Is | How to Order It |
|---|---|---|
| Loaded Fries | Fries topped with cheese sauce and crumbled bacon | “Fries with cheese sauce and bacon on top” |
| Bacon Cheese Fries | Fries with melted cheese and bacon pieces | “Cheese fries with bacon” |
| Bacon and Grilled Onion Fries | Fries topped with bacon and caramelized grilled onions | “Fries with bacon and grilled onions” |
| Grilled Cheese | Melted cheese on a grilled bun | “A grilled cheese sandwich” |
| Fried Okra | Crispy fried okra as a side | “Fried okra as my side” (ask if available that day) |
| Walking Taco | Taco meat and toppings served in a chip bag | “Taco meat and toppings in a chip bag” |
Secret Menu Shakes
Cook Out already lets you mix any two shake flavors free of charge, so the shake side of the cookout secret menu is really a list of combinations fans swear by. For a ranked rundown of the regular shake menu, see our guide to the best Cookout milkshake flavors.
| Secret Shake | Flavors Combined | How to Order It |
|---|---|---|
| PB and M&M | Peanut butter and M&M | “A peanut butter and M&M shake” |
| Chocolate Banana Pudding | Chocolate and banana pudding | “A chocolate and banana pudding shake” |
| Banana Split Shake | Strawberry, banana, and chocolate | “A shake with strawberry, banana, and chocolate” |
| Cheesecake Extravaganza | Cheesecake base with extra mix-ins | “A cheesecake shake with extra mix-ins” |
| PB Banana | Peanut butter and banana | “A peanut butter and banana shake” |
| Chocolate Cherry | Chocolate and cherry | “A chocolate and cherry shake” |
| Pineapple Cheesecake | Pineapple and cheesecake | “A pineapple and cheesecake shake” |
| Custom Two-Flavor Mix | Any two flavors from the menu | Name both flavors; mixing is free |
Secret Drinks and Desserts
| Secret Item | What It Is | How to Order It |
|---|---|---|
| Cheerwine Float | Cheerwine soda poured over vanilla ice cream | “A Cheerwine float” |
| Coke Float | Coca-Cola poured over vanilla ice cream | “A Coke float” |
| Loaded Cheesecake Slice | A cheesecake slice with extra toppings | “A cheesecake slice with extra toppings” |
| Walnut Brownie | A brownie topped with walnuts | “A brownie with walnuts” |
The 5 Secret Orders Worth Trying First
- Peanut butter bacon burger. The most famous secret order for a reason. Order it as “a burger with peanut butter and bacon.”
- Banana split shake. Strawberry, banana, and chocolate blended thick. It costs the standard shake price.
- Loaded fries. Fries with cheese sauce and bacon on top. Hearty enough to share.
- Cheerwine float. Carolina cherry soda over vanilla ice cream.
- Quesadilla burger. A beef patty folded inside a grilled quesadilla.
One more unique menu item worth trying is the walking taco taco meat, cheese, and toppings served right in a chip bag. See our full breakdown for what’s inside and the current price.
How to Order from the Cookout Secret Menu
- Describe ingredients, never nicknames. Say “a burger with peanut butter and bacon,” not a fan-made name.
- Order at off-peak times. Custom builds take extra attention from the crew.
- Keep it simple. One or two modifications per item is reasonable.
- Be polite and patient. You are asking for something off the board.
- Accept no gracefully. Some locations or shifts cannot do certain builds.
How Much Do Secret Menu Items Cost?
Secret menu items are priced as the regular items they are built from. A peanut butter burger rings up as a standard burger, and secret shakes cost the standard shake price of about $3.99. There are no official secret menu prices because there is no official secret menu.
Cookout Secret Menu FAQs
Is there an official Cook Out secret menu?
No. Cook Out has never published an official secret menu. Every item on this page is a fan-created custom order built from standard menu ingredients.
How do I order from the cookout secret menu?
Describe the ingredients you want, not the nickname. Say “a burger with peanut butter and bacon” rather than using a fan-made name, order during off-peak hours, and keep the build to one or two modifications.
Do secret menu items cost more than regular items?
Usually not. Secret builds are priced as the regular items they are made from, with small upcharges only for premium add-ons like extra bacon.
Can every Cook Out location make secret menu items?
It varies by location, crew, and how busy the store is. Most stores will build simple custom orders from ingredients they stock, but availability is never guaranteed.
What is the best secret menu burger at Cook Out?
The peanut butter bacon burger is the fan favorite. The salty-sweet mix of peanut butter, bacon, and char-grilled beef is the most recommended secret order.
What is the best secret menu shake at Cook Out?
The banana split shake, made with strawberry, banana, and chocolate, is the most popular secret shake. Any two shake flavors can be mixed free.
What is the best secret menu side at Cook Out?
Loaded fries topped with cheese sauce and bacon. It turns the standard fries into a shareable side.
The cookout secret menu rewards curious ordering. Stick to ingredient descriptions, keep builds simple, and you can eat like a regular while trying combinations most customers never think to ask for. Find the nearest Cook Out location to try these builds yourself.
